Cellulose vs Asbestos: How To Tell The Difference

Asbestos is a toxic, cancer-causing material that was widely used for insulation purposes a few decades ago. Once the toxic effects of asbestos became known to public its use was replaced by cellulose. Many old homes may still have insulation made if asbestos. So how do you know if your home’s insulation has asbestos, how to tell between asbestos and cellulose insulation?

It is hard to visually tell the difference between asbestos and cellulose insulation. However, Asbestos insulation is generally pebble like and is greayish brown or solver-gold in color whereas cellulose insulation is greyish and looks like shredded paper.

However, since the amount of asbestos used in different insulations vary so do their appearances. Therefore, if you suspect that your home has asbestos insulation, it is recommended to call a professional to asses it.

asbestos vs cellulose: tell the difference
Asbestos vs cellulose insulation

If you are interested in knowming more about cellulose and asbestos insulation, continue reading.

Cellulose Insulation

Known to be one of the oldest forms of home insulation, cellulose insulation is typically made from recycled paper products, like newsprint, cardboard boxes, and other paper, as a result of which the recycled material content here tends to be up to 85%. To make cellulose, the paper used is shredded to pieces and fiberized, making it feasible to be packed tightly for insulation purposes.

Cellulose insulation
cellulose insulation

Cellulose insulation can be installed in both newly constructed homes as well as existing structures. The material can be installed following the loose-fill or blown-in insulation method; this is a method where the material used will be shredded or broken into smaller pieces/granules to achieve a fluffy appearance, and densely packed in different areas around the building, such as attics, walls, ceilings, crawl spaces, etc. One huge benefit of blown-in cellulose insulation is that it does not require an additional moisture barrier, which thereby brings down installation costs.

Advantages of Cellulose

Environment-friendly

One of the top reasons why cellulose is currently a widely preferred and used insulation materials is that it is environment-friendly. This is because, as mentioned earlier, the material is derived from reused and recycled materials that would otherwise get disposed in landfills.

Low VOC Levels

Blown-in cellulose, according to a report by Healthy Building Science, has low VOC (Volatile Organic Compound) levels – chemicals that are harmful to the environment and human health. In fact, the total VOC (TVOC) of this insulation type is known to be significantly lesser than what is permitted in GREENGUARD certified products.

Soundproofing

If you happen to live near a highway or railway tracks, or you generally prefer to be in a quieter environment, cellulose insulation would be the ideal choice for your home. Since the material is a lot denser than many other insulation materials, it has excellent soundproofing ability.

Disadvantages of Cellulose

Not Waterproof

Cellulose is not waterproof by nature. Yes, it can and will be treated with various chemicals during insulation to make it water resistant to an extent; however, if it gets exposed to moisture to an extended period, it can lead to huge problems, including mold.

Fire Hazard

As the major composition in cellulose is recycled paper, it happens to be a fire hazard if not treated with fire retardants during insulation. It is to eliminate this hazard that building codes throughout the country require cellulose insulation to be properly treated with fire retardants before use.

Asbestos Insulation

Used since the 1950s, asbestos is a natural mineral that is known for its corrosion- and heat-resistant properties. Asbestos insulation refers to any building insulation material that contains asbestos. The fibrous nature of this material gives it an appearance and texture similar to cotton, and its ability to slow down heat transfer through its fibers makes it highly heat-resistant.

asbestos insulation
Asbestos insulation

If you live in an older home, chances are high that your building insulation contains a significant percentage of asbestos.

Advantages of Asbestos

  • Asbestos has high heat-resistant capability, which means it does not burn easily.
  • Since its thermal insulation capacity is high, it can make a building more energy-efficient.
  • Asbestos is also weather-proof.
  • It is highly durable, which is why you can still find asbestos insulation intact in any older buildings.
  • The material is less expensive.
  • It is easy to clean and maintain as well.

Disadvantages of Asbestos

  • As many of you would probably be aware, asbestos is extremely dangerous to human health and the environment. The fibrous microparticles in the material, when inhaled or swallowed, can lead to various illnesses.

Risks

Asbestos produces microscopic fibers that can be swallowed or inhaled, which in turn can result in a plethora of issues. Since it is very difficult for the human body to break down asbestos, its toxic fibers, over time, can lead to inflammation, lung cancer, ovarian cancer, mesothelioma, genetic cell damage, and more such illnesses. Due to such risks involved with asbestos, governments around the world have banned its use as an insulation material. But, there are still some insulation materials that contain asbestos, like vermiculite, which need to be identified and replaced.

Where to Find Asbestos?

If you live in a house that was passed down generations or purchased an older property to live in or rent out, it could possibly be insulated with asbestos or other materials containing a percentage of asbestos. But, where can you find asbestos around your building? These are the few places you should check first: attics, crawl spaces, basement, ceilings, walls, and closets.

The Differences

Unfortunately, in terms of appearance, both cellulose and asbestos insulations look very similar – thick, dense, fluffy, and lumpy in texture. However, currently, the most common insulation material that contains asbestos is vermiculite, which typically looks like grayish-brown pebbles.

As for the other differences, it is clear that asbestos or asbestos-filled insulation materials are harmful and should be avoided at all costs. If you are doubtful that your building might contain the same, it is highly recommended that you hire professional contractors to inspect your building and do the needful to reduce or eliminate the risk of exposure and contamination.

Charles John

A novice DIYer who learns about home ventilation. I am a mechanical engineer and have a basic knowledge of HVAC systems but I learn continuously to make myself the best blogger in that space.

Latest Posts