The right number of blades on ceiling and standing fans has always been a topic of debate. Should you choose a fan with 3, 4, or with 5 blades? If you are wondering what the differences between them are, and how the number of blades affects their performance, continue reading.
Irrespective of whether the fans are installed on the ceiling or free-standing, the effects of the number of blades on them are the same. For a quick and easy comparison, I am comparing the 3 and 5-bladed fans since they are at extremes. Below are the main differences between them;
- Fans with five blades tend to be more aesthetically pleasing than three-bladed fans.
- Three-blade ceiling and pedestal fans are more energy-efficient than five-bladed fans due to less drag on the fan’s motor.
- The wind chill effect from three blade fans is better.
- If you prefer a breeze effect and not gust, fans with five blades are a better choice
- Five blade ceiling andstanding fans are much quieter than three bladed ones.
- The five-blade fans provide a more uniform flow of air than the three blade fans.
- Five blade fans cost more than three-bladed fans.
Detailed comparison of different aspects of 3, 4, and 5 blade fans
The number of blades a fan (ceiling fan or pedestal) has affects its wind speed, noise, energy efficiency, cost and airflow. In addition, there is the aesthetics part. So it makes sense to compare all three types of fans based on the above factors.
Wind speed – which one moves air faster
Simply put, wind speed is the speed of wind coming from a fan. It is much different from the term airflow, which is a measure of the total air moved by the fan.
Wind speed is what causes the wind chill effect from a fan. It accelerates the heat loss from our body, making us feel that the room is cooler than it actually is. (Do ceiling fans really cool a room?) The more the wind speed, the cooler you feel.
A 3 blade fan moves air faster than a 4 blade fan, and a four blade fan moves air faster than a 5 blade fan. If you are looking for that chill effect and a gust of wind then 3 blade fans are the best. As the number of blades increases, the wind speed slows down, and you get a more uniform wind, like a breeze.
Standing fans, when compared to ceiling fans, have more wind speed. This is because standing fans have a higher blade pitch, and they also tend to spin faster to compensate for their shorter blade spans.
Noise – which is quieter?
The more blades a fan has, the quieter it is. Here, I am not referring to the noise from the fan motor but the wind noise the fan makes. As mentioned above, fans with less number of blades, a 3 blade fan, for example, have higher wind speeds causing more noise. On the other hand, a 5 blade fan offers a more uniform wind flow, thus reducing overall ambient noise.
As you can guess, the noise from a 4 blade fan sits in the middle of the two.
We can also compare the noise from a standing fan and a ceiling fan based on wind speed. Standing/pedestal fans have higher wind speeds than ceiling fans, so they are noisier.
Energy efficiency
When it comes to energy efficiency;
- 3 blade fans have the highest energy efficiency
- 4 blade fans have medium energy efficiency
- 5 blade fans score the least in energy efficiency
Please note that the above statement is based on the assumption that all other factors, like CFM, blade span, pitch, motor type etc are the same across all the fans compared.
Why does energy efficiency go down for fans with more blades/vanes?
This is due to a factor called drag. If we assume that the blade pitch (tilt of the fan blades) and the motor power are the same for a 3-blade and 5 blade fan, the latter fan’s motor will have to work harder to move air. This results in reduced energy efficiency. This is the reason why wind turbines have only two or three blades.
Given all other factors are the same, a four bladed fan is more energy efficient than a 5 blade one but less than a 3-blade fan.
Airflow (CFM) – which one moves more air
It is hard to compare the airflow rate and the number of blades a fan has. The CFM depends on the blade pitch, blade span and the motor power of a fan than the number of blades. Assuming that these factors remain the same, a 3-blade fan may move more air than a 4 or a 5 blade fan since it has less drag.
However, practically the fans are made to match a prefixed CFM value, and factors like pitch, motor power etc are designed to attain this final CFM value. So it is not possible to compare blade numbers and airflow directly.
Price
Generally speaking, the price of a fan increases with the number of blades it has. So, a 5-blade fan is going to be more expensive than a 3-blade fan with the 4-blade fan priced in the middle.
It is also worth mentioning that the more blades a fan has, the more will be its motor power, which adds to the cost. Also, fans with 6 or more blades are made mostly for aesthetics, therefore, their prices will be much higher.
Looks
Looks are subjective. There are really good-looking fans across 3, 4, and 5 blade categories. I can’t speak for everyone but I am not a fan of 4-blade fans; they look kind of odd. I think 5 blade fans have more aesthetic choices than 3 blade ones. But as I said before, it is subjective.
Popularity
In the United States of America, 3-blade fans are the most popular followed by 5-blade fans. Fans with 4 blades are teh least popular among the three. Given below is a popularity chart taken from Google Trends report proving this.
Which is better: 3, 4 or 5 blades?
If you are looking for an economical fan with good airflow rates, go for a three-bladed fan. If your priority is aesthetics and quietness I recommend a 5-blade fan. If you want a mix of all, 4 blade fans can be considered.
Related posts
